In honor of Georgetown's 25 years in Patriot League play, we have compiled an unofficial list of some of Georgetown's greatest players by position in a 25-man team covering the 2001 to 2026 teams: offense, defense, and three from special teams. Not all could be cited, especially on defense, but the output is an attempt to recognize some of the major contributors to Georgetown's growth and success over is first quarter century of play in the league.
(In 1940, readers of the Alumni Bulletin picked an "All-Time Team" across 60 seasons of Georgetown Football. Read more about it here.)
(In 1940, readers of the Alumni Bulletin picked an "All-Time Team" across 60 seasons of Georgetown Football. Read more about it here.)
![]() |
Nick Alfieri (2011-14)LB, Portland, ORFirst team All-Patriot League 2014, second team 2013. Third all-time in career tackles (322). Team captain, 2014, Eacobacci Memorial recipient, 2014. |
![]() |
Maurice Banks (2002-05)DB, Clinton, MDSecond team All-Patriot League 2004, 2005. 10th all time in unassisted tackles (113). John Hagerty Award recipient (outstanding back), 2005. Served as assistant coach in 2010 and 2014 through 2018. Head coach, Gettysburg College, 2020 through 2025. |
![]() |
Alex Buzbee (2003-06)DL, Chester, PAThree time all-Patriot League selection: first team 2006; second team 2004, 2005. Three year starter, finished fifth all-time in career sacks, and placed in top five of PL during his junior and senior seasons. Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2014. Played on the Washington Redskins practice squad and promoted to active roster at end of 2007 season, also played two seasons with the CFL Toronto Argonauts. |
![]() |
Henry Darmstadter (2013-16)PK, Alexandria, VASecond team All-Patriot League 2015,2016, only Georgetown place kicker named to two all-PL teams. Holds Georgetown record for most career field goals (27), second all-time in completion percentage (73.0 percent). Career long 49 yard FG versus Holy Cross, 2016. Played graduate season at Maryland, 2017. |
![]() |
Michael Dereus (2016-19)WR, Hyde Park, MAFirst team All-Patriot League 2019, second team 2017. Led team in receiving three consecutive seasons (2017,18,19), seventh all time in receiving yardage (1,879). Returned kickoff 100 yards versus Holy Cross, 2016. Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2019. Free agent signee of Baltimore Ravens, 2020; played two seasons for Birmingham Stallions in USFL (2022-23). |
![]() |
Mac Hollensteiner (2018-22)OL, Bethesda, MDSecond team All-Patriot League, 2022. Two year starter on offensive line. Two-time recipient of George Murtagh Award (outstanding lineman) in 2021 and 2022. |
![]() |
Ryan Jelinek (2016-19)OL, Pittsburgh, PASecond team All-Patriot League, 2019. Started 24 games over three seasons, team captain and George Murtagh Award recipient, 2019. |
![]() |
Jayah Kaisamba (2008-11)DB, Fort Worth, TXFirst team All-Patriot League, 2011, first Georgetown defensive back named to a PL first team. Led the Patriot League and finished 30th in the nation in pass defense as a senior. Ranked eighth nationally in interceptions in 2011. |
![]() |
Jimmy Kibble (2022-25)WR, Leesburg, VAFirst team All-Patriot League, 2025, second team 2023, 2024. Fourth all-time in career receiving yards (2,593), fifth all-time in receiving touchdowns (15). Led team in receiving three consecutive seasons. One of five Georgetown players with 1,000 or more receiving yards in a season. Signed by the New England Patriots, 2026. |
![]() |
Jo'el Kimpela (2012-15)RB, Euless, TXSecond team All-Patriot League, 2015, 2016. Fourth all-time in career rushing yards (1,945). His 838 rushing yards in 2014 is the second most for Georgetown in the Patriot League era. Eacobacci Memorial recipient, 2015. |
![]() |
Alec May (2011-14)DL, Wrenthem, MASecond team All-American, 2014. First team All-Patriot League, 2015, second team 2014. Led the nation in sacks in 2014 (16.5), third all time at Georgetown in career sacks (29). Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2014. |
![]() |
Luke McArdle (2000-03)WR/PR, Boxford, MAFirst Georgetown player awarded first-team All-Patriot League. Led the nation in 2003 in all-purpose yards (199.5/game) and among top ten in receiving yards per game, scoring, and punt return average. All-time Georgetown leader in all-purpose yards, holds school records for career punt returns (80) and punt return yardage (951). Two-time Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2002,03. |
![]() |
Robert McCabe (2009-12)LB, Newtown Square, MAConsensus All-America, 2012. First team All-Patriot League, 2011, 2012, Patriot League Defensive Player Of The Year, 2012. Led the nation in tackles, 2012. Holds school records for most tackles in a season (159), most unassisted tackles in a career (188) and most tackles in a career (407). Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2012. |
![]() |
Jeremy Moore (2009-12)DB, New Haven, CTFirst Team All-Patriot League, 2011, 2012, second team 2010. Holds school record for career interception yardage (318), second all-time in single game kickoff return yardage (206), second in career kickoff returns (81) and second in career return yardage (1,883). |
![]() |
Kyle Nolan (2012-15)QB, Branford, CTCareer leader in passing completions (565) and attempts (1,011), second all-time in yardage (5,750), fourth all-time in touchdowns thrown (38). Holds record for longest run from scrimmage for Georgetown in PL era, a 82 yard run versus Holy Cross in 2013. |
![]() |
Michael Ononibaku (2002-05)DL, Amherst, MASecond team All-America, 2005. First Team All-Patriot League, 2004, 2005, second team 2003. Fourth all time in career sacks (28), eighth in nation in sacks in 2004. Al Blozis MVP recipient, 2004,05, first defensive player ever named MVP in consecutive seasons. Team captain, 2005, Eacobacci Memorial Recipient, 2004,05. Robert A. Duffey Scholar-Athlete Award recipient, 2005, one of only two football players awarded in the PL era. |
![]() |
Talati Polomalu (2019-23)OL, Sandy, ORSecond Team All-Patriot League, 2021, 2022. George Murtagh Award recipient, 2022. |
![]() |
Mike Roland (2011-14)OL, Miami, FLSecond Team All-Patriot League, 2011, 2014, started 43 consecutive games from 2011 through 2014. Team captain, 2014. |
![]() |
Andrew Schaetzke (2008-11)DL, Toledo, OHFirst team All-America, 2011. First team All-Patriot League, 2010, 2011, Patriot League Defensive Player Of The Year, 2011. Led the PL and was ranked among the top 10 nationally in sacks and tackles for loss. Finished fourth nationally for the Buck Buchanan Award (nation's outstanding defensive player). Second all-time in career sacks (30). Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2010,11. |
![]() |
Joshua Stakely (2019-23)RB, Madisonville, TNSecond team All-Patriot League, 2023, Only player to lead Georgetown in rushing four consecutive seasons. Fourth all time in career rushing attempts and the most among any player in the PL era (431), fifth in career yardage (1,913), seventh in career touchdowns (19). Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2023. |
![]() |
Khristian Tate (2016-19)DL, Warner Robins, GAFour time all-Patriot League selection: first team 2017,2018; second team 2016, 2019. Started 28 consecutive games before injury his senior season, ninth all-time in career sacks. Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2017. |
![]() |
Joshua Tomas (2018-22)WR, University Park, ILThird team All-America, 2022. First team all-Patriot League 2021, second team 2022. Career leader in pass receptions (227) and second in receiving yardage (2,835), Tomas led FCS in receptions and yards per game in 2022 and finished second nationally in receiving yards (1,231). Two-time Al Blozis MVP recipient, 2021,2022. |
![]() |
Kyle Van Fleet (2004-07)FB, Williamsport, PASecond Team All-Patriot League and PL Scholar Athlete of the Year, 2007. National semifinalist, Draddy Award. Led team in receiving yardage, 2005, 2007. Al Blozis MVP recipient, 2007. Robert A. Duffey Scholar-Athlete Award recipient, 2007. |
![]() |
Dustin Wharton (2010-13)LB, LaVale, MDTwo-time first team All-Patriot League, 2012, 2013. Fourth all-time in tackles (280). Team captain, 2013, Al Blozis MVP Award recipient, 2013. |
![]() |
Ahmad Wilson (2017-21)DB, Pittsburgh, PAThree time all-Patriot League selection: first team 2019, 2021; second team 2018. Academic All-American, 2021, Georgetown's only three time Academic All-Patriot League selection per PL records. Top-15 all time in tackles (206). Two time John Hagerty Award recipient, 2019, 2021. Eacobacci Memorial recipient, 2021. |
























