In 1939, readers of the Alumni Bulletin (the predecessor publication to Georgetown Magazine) voted on an all time team of Georgetown Football, dating back to the 1881 season. The results were announced in the February 14, 1940 issue of The HOYA and is presented below. All members in the first two teams are members of the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame.
(In 2026, this site selected an "All-PL Team" of 25 outstanding players across the first 25 seasons of Georgetown in the Patriot League. Read more about it here.)
(In 2026, this site selected an "All-PL Team" of 25 outstanding players across the first 25 seasons of Georgetown in the Patriot League. Read more about it here.)
First Team | |
![]() |
Paul Florence (1921-23)(1900-1986)E, Chicago, IL A three sport letterman at Georgetown, Florence was its leading receiver over two seasons. Left Georgetown after the 1923 season to play professional baseball and saw action for the 1926 New York Giants. Elected to Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame, 1953. |
![]() |
Jim Mooney (1926-29)(1907-1944)T/P, Chicago, IL Georgetown's greatest kicker, Mooney was selected to the Associated Press 2nd team for his work as a tackle, but it was his punting that won over the sportswriters, including a 55 yard punt in the final seconds that preserved a 7-2 Georgetown victory before 50,000 at Yankee Stadium. Averaged 60 yards per punt in a 1929 game; his season average of 45.0 yards per punt in 1928 has not been equalled by a Georgetown kicker since. Played in NFL six seasons before military service, killed in action during World War II. Posthumously elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Harry Connaughton (1924-26)(1905-1969)G/T, Philadelphia, PA Georgetown's only consensus All-America in its major college era: a dominant lineman given his size for the era (6-4, 250). Recipient of Philadelphia sportswriters' poll as MVP of Eastern football, 1926. Played one season in NFL before pursuing legal career. Elected to Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame, 1953. |
![]() |
Claude Grigsby (1925-27)(1903-1965)C, Chicago, IL The star player on both sides of the line in a Georgetown offensive line that scored 377 points and a defense that allowed only one single touchdown en route to a 8-1 season. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Sam Cordovano (1927-1929)(1906-1995)G, Buffalo, NY Honorable Mention All-America, 1929. Later served as offensive coordinator for Lou Little at Columbia (1930-43) and was one of the co-founders of the Buffalo Bills of the AAFC. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Rudy Comstock (1919-22)(1900-1975)T, Pawhuska, OK Four year starter under coach Al Exendine, he won four NFL titles as a player from 1923 through 1933, including the New York Giants and Green Bay Packers. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Frank McGrath (1924-26)(1904-1990)E, Bay City, MI Team captain, 1926, dominant tackler on Georgetown teams which went 16-4-1 in 1925 and 1926. Two seasons in NFL. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Harry Costello (1910-13)(1891-1968)QB/P/K, Meriden, CT All-East, 1912, 1913. Georgetown's greatest quarterback. Despite his size (5-7, 136 pounds) Costello was known as a "quadruple threat" as a rusher, passer, punter and drop-kicker over his four seasons. Famously cited by Pop Warner as "for his [size], he is one of the greatest players that ever lived." Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Jack Hagerty (1923-25)(1903-1982)HB, Boston, MA All-East, 1925. Played six seasons for New York Giants before being offered head coaching position at Georgetown midway through 1932 season, Georgetown head coach, 1932-48; athletic director 1949-69. John Carroll Award recipient, 1972. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
John Gilroy (1915-17)(1896-1952)RB/K, Haverhill, MA All-America, 1916. Georgetown's greatest ruinning back: led the nation in rushing and punt returns in 1916: ran for 20 touchdowns in the season, threw for 10 more, and once scored six touchdowns and kicked 11 extra points in a single game. His career record of 37 rushing touchdowns remains a Georgetown record. Drafted by Jim Thorpe to play for his first NFL team in 1920. Posthumously elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1958. |
![]() |
Jack Flavin (1918-22)(1900-1965)RB/P, Portland, ME All-South Atlantic, 1922. Three sport athlete, holds school record for 99 yard punt versus Holy Cross, 1921. Played two years in the NFL. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
| |
![]() |
William Cusack (1913-16)(1896-1975)E, Washington, DC All-East, 1916. Pursued his medical degree at Georgetown after college, served as professor of obstetrics at Georgetown University and as a personal physician of the Kennedy family. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1958. |
![]() |
Thomas Moriarty (1911-13)(1892-1985)T, Springfield, MA Nicknamed "Ooch", Moriarty was a three year starter on Georgetown teams from 1911 through 1913. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
George Murtagh (1923-25)(1904-1993)G, Jersey City, NJ A mainstay of the lineups under Lou Little in the 1920s, Murtagh played seven years as center for the NFL's New York Giants before Georgetown an NFL teammate Jack Hagerty recruited him back to the Hilltop to serve as offensive coordinator from 1932 to 1948. He later served as director of the University's Physical Education department from 1949 through 1969. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
J. Percy Given (1901-04)(1883-1944)C, Beavertown, PA All-South, 1901, 1902. Though it had been nearly 40 years since he last played, alumni in the poll fondly remembered Percy Given, a towering 225 lb. center for four seasons at the turn of the century, with the Washington Post once calling him "the greatest center Georgetown has ever had." Posthumously elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Maurice Dubofsky (1929-31)(1909-1970)G, Hartford, CT Honorable mention All-America, 1932. Anchored a Georgetown defensive line under the tutelage of assistant coach Frank Leahy that held opponents to under nine points a game. Defensive coordinator, 1932-48, head coach 1968-69. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Dan O'Connor (1915-16)(1894-1964)T, Manchester, NH Team captain, 1916. Played two years in the NFL, 1920, 1921. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Ken Provincial (1927-1929)(1900-1978)E, Messena, NY Two year starter, long remembered for an 87 yard fumble return for touchdown in Georgetown's 7-2 win over NYU before 50,000 at Yankee Stadium. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Bob Gormley (1924-1926)Vital statistics under researchQB, Bridgeport, CT Starting quarterback of 1925 team which went 9-1 and fell one point short of an undefeated season. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
![]() |
Joe Mellendick (1937-1938)(1917-1975)RB/P, Baltimore, MD Team captain, 1939; was injured prior to his senior year following two standout seasons at running back. Later played minor league baseball before serving as a coach in the Baltimore Orioles' farm system. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1975. |
![]() |
Jackie Maloney (1915-1917; 1919)(1896-1971)QB, Boston, MA Selected as a running back in the poll, Maloney actually played quarterback for four seasons under Al Exendine, including the 7-1 season of 1915, Was a popular figure among alumni after graduation, and served as head coach for 1923 season. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1964. |
![]() |
Tony Plansky (1922-1924)(1900-1979)RB, Boston, MA Third team All-American and All-East, 1925. A three sport athlete, Plansky played baseball and track in addition to football: he won the AAU decathlon in 1924 and two Penn Relays championships. Narrowly missed 1928 Olympic qualifying, he played three seasons with NFL's New York Giants and nine seasons in minor league baseball. In 2019, Sports Illustrated named him the 14th greatest athlete ever from the commonwealth of Massachusetts. Elected to the Georgetown University Athletic Hall of Fame in 1953. |
| |
|
E: Carl Waite (1924-26, White Plains, NY) T: Otto Saur (1923-27, Bridgeport, CT) T: Clem Stralka (1935-37, Glen Lyon, PA) T: Wayne Hart (1911, Washington, DC) G: Augie Lio (1938-40, Boston, MA G: Jerry Carroll (1925-28, Cresco, IA) C: John Petritz (1911-14, Rockford, IL RB: Bill Kenyon (1919-22, Manchester, NH) RB: Leon Martel (1903-04, Weymouth, MA RB: Steve Barabas,(1926-29, Jersey City, NJ) | |





















