METRO ATLANTIC ATHLETIC CONFERENCE (1993-1999) |
| 1st Team | 2nd team | |
| 1993 | Murray Happer, OL | John Callaway, OL |
| Dave Powilatis, DL | Beau Riely, OL | |
| Tom Wonica, LB | Brendan Gaughan, K | |
| Joe Eacobacci, DB | ||
| Chris Fazio, DB | ||
| Joe Piscatella, P | ||
| 1994 | Tom Wonica, LB | Derek DeBakker, OL |
| Steve Colello, OL | Jim Klessel, DL | |
| Murray Happer, OL | Eric Behrens, LB | |
| Steve Iorio, RB | Chris Johnston, DB | |
| Joe Piscatella, P | ||
| 1995 | Tom Wonica, LB (Defensive POY) | Joe Eacobacci, DB |
| Steve Ozeranic, OL | Enrico Mariani, DL | |
| Derek DeBakker, OL | Eric Behrens, LB | |
| Tom Wonica, LB | Sam Wales, DB | |
| Chris Johnston, DB | ||
| 1996 | Janne Kouri, DT (Defensive POY) | Steve Iorio, RB |
| Don Garrett, OL | Steve Ozeranic, OL | |
| Sean Brady, OL | Mike Fioritto, DL | |
| Dennis Hermonstyne, DB | Mike Halen, DL | |
| Mike Lynn, LB | ||
| Dan Cunniffe, DB | ||
| Charlie Turner, P | ||
| 1997 | Bill Ward, QB | Steve Iorio, RB |
| Rob Rosenthal, WR | Joe Todisco, RB | |
| Steve Ozeranic, OL | Greg Rachinsky, TE | |
| Skender Daerti, OL | Ryan Johnson, OL | |
| Robert Quigley, C | Steve Pogorelec, DL | |
| Peter Carbonara, K | Jeff Heyn, DL | |
| Mike Fioritto, DL | Mike Melchionda, LB | |
| Mike Halen, DL | Reid Ruberti, DB | |
| Mike Lynn, LB | ||
| Dennis Hermonstyne, DB | ||
| 1998 | Gharun Hester, WR | J.J. Mont, QB |
| Skender Daerti, OL | Rob Belli, RB | |
| Scott Wolfe, OL | Bill Rutkoske, TE | |
| Mike Melchionda, LB | Robert Quigley, C | |
| Anthony Bartolomeo, DB | Kevin Merse, OL | |
| Mike Halen, DL | ||
| 1999 | J.J. Mont, QB (Offensive POY) | Scott Wolfe, OL |
| Jim Gallagher, DB (Defensive POY) | Bob Lenihan, OL | |
| Gharun Hester, WR | Ben Tortolani, OL | |
| Robert Quigley, C | ||
| Kevin Merse, OL | ||
| Paul Miller, DL | ||
| Adam Krugman, LB | ||
PATRIOT LEAGUE (2001-) |
| 1st Team | 2nd team | |
| 2001 | No selections | No selections |
| 2002 | No selections | David Paulus, P |
| 2003 | Luke McArdle, WR | Matt Fronczke, LB |
| Michael Ononibaku, DE | ||
| 2004 | Michael Ononibaku, DE | Maurice Banks, DB |
| Alex Buzbee, DE | ||
| 2005 | Michael Ononibaku, DE | Maurice Banks, DB |
| Alex Buzbee, DE | ||
| 2006 | Alex Buzbee, DE | Brian Tandy, DB |
| 2007 | No selections | Kyle Van Fleet, FB |
| 2008 | No selections | Ataefiok Etukeren, DL |
| Travis Mack, DB | ||
| 2009 | No selections | Chudi Obianwu, DL |
| 2010 | Andrew Schaetzke, DL (Defensive POY) | Nick Parrish, LB |
| Jayah Kaisamba, DB | Jeremy Moore, DB | |
| 2011 | Andrew Schaetzke, DE | Nick Campanella, RB |
| Robert McCabe, LB | Mike Roland, OL | |
| Jeremy Moore, DB, KR | Brett Weiss, K | |
| Jayah Kaisamba, DB | ||
| 2012 | Robert McCabe, LB (Defensive POY) | Kevin Macari, WR |
| Dustin Wharton, LB | James Spaly, OL | |
| Jeremy Moore, DB | Nick Campanella, RB | |
| 2013 | Dustin Wharton, LB | Daniel Sprotte, TE |
| Alec May, DL | ||
| Nick Alfieri, LB | ||
| 2014 | Alec May, DL | Mike Roland, OL |
| Nick Alfieri, LB | Jo'el Kimpela, RB | |
| Jordan Richardson, DL | ||
| Ettian Scott, DB | ||
| 2015 | Matthew Satchell, LB | Matthew Buckman, TE |
| Justin Hill, WR | ||
| Jo'el Kimpela, RB | ||
| Kevin Liddy, OL | ||
| Henry Darmstadter, K | ||
| Ettian Scott, DB | ||
| 2016 | Hunter Kiselick, LS | Henry Darmstadter, K |
| J'Von Butler, LB | ||
| Leo Loughrey, LB | ||
| Khristian Tate, DL | ||
| Harry McCollum, P | ||
| 2017 | Khristian Tate, DL | Michael Dereus, WR |
| Ahmad Wilson, LB | Isaac Ellsworth, RS | |
| Davis Akere, DB | ||
| 2018 | Khristian Tate, DL | Owen Kessler, DL |
| Duval Paul, DL | ||
| Wes Bowers, LB | ||
| Jethro Francois, DB | ||
| Ahmad Wilson, LB | ||
| 2019 | Ahmad Wilson, LB | Isaac Schley, HB 1 |
| Ryan Jelinek, OL | ||
| Khristian Tate, DL | ||
| Xavier Reddick, LB | ||
| Palmer Nix, LB | ||
| Brad Hurst, P | ||
| 2021 | Joshua Tomas, WR | Zach Jewell, RB |
| Ahmad Wilson, LB | Talati Polomalu, OL | |
| Conor Hunt, K | Ibrahim Kamara, DL | |
| Owen Kessler, DB | ||
| 2022 | No selections | Pierce Holley, QB |
| Joshua Tomas, WR | ||
| Mac Hollensteiner, OL | ||
| Talati Polomalu, OL | ||
| Mason Gudger, RS | ||
| Ibrahim Kamara, DL | ||
| Justin Fonteneaux, LB | ||
| Wedner Cadet, DB | ||
| Brock Biestek, Special Teams | ||
| 2023 | Mateen Ibirogba, DL | Joshua Stakely, RB |
| Nicholas Dunneman, WR, RS | ||
| Jimmy Kibble, WR | ||
| Ibri Harrell, DL | ||
| Rashon Adams Jr, DB | ||
| Jaden Dugger, DB | ||
| Will Kessler, Special Teams | ||
| 1 Selected for halfback, but played tight end. | ||